905-571-7441
“Why Do They Shut Down When I Get Closer?”
It’s one of the most heartbreaking and confusing dynamics in a relationship:
You reach for your partner—emotionally, physically, or even just in conversation—and instead of drawing near, they pull away.
Maybe they go quiet. Maybe they leave the room. Maybe they suddenly seem distracted, irritable, or disinterested.
And you’re left wondering: Did I do something wrong? Are they losing interest? Why do they back off just when things feel most vulnerable—or most real?
If this cycle sounds familiar, you’re not alone. Many couples struggle with this dance of closeness and distance. And beneath the frustration is often something deeper—attachment patterns, unspoken fears, and the longing to feel safe in love.
Let’s break it down—gently and compassionately.
When Love Feels Like a Push-Pull: Understanding Attachment Triggers
What looks like avoidance on the surface is often a protective strategy underneath. One of the most common explanations for this pattern comes from attachment theory, a well-researched framework that helps explain how we behave in close relationships.
Why Do People Pull Away When Things Get Close?
For many adults, especially those with avoidant attachment styles, emotional closeness can feel threatening—even if they deeply love their partner.
Some common reasons your partner might pull away:
- Fear of vulnerability or being “seen” too deeply
- Unresolved trauma or trust injuries from past relationships
- A belief that closeness leads to control or loss of independence
- Discomfort with strong emotions—their own or yours
- Feeling Overwhelmed in moments of intimacy or confrontation
This doesn’t mean they don’t care. It means that closeness, for them, activates a kind of internal alarm. And pulling away becomes a coping mechanism. One of my colleagues likens this response to stepping back from a cliff. Our emotions are part of our guidance system and when we feel uncomfortable, we react. This can result in the Pursuer Distancer Dance (Fogerty,1976).
Anxious Meets Avoidant: A Common Relationship Dynamic
If you tend to crave more closeness and reassurance in relationships (anxious attachment), your partner pulling away may feel devastating. And the more they pull away, the more you may reach out—asking, texting, explaining, pleading—trying to bridge the gap.
This can create what’s known as the anxious-avoidant cycle:
- The more you reach, the more they withdraw.
- The more they withdraw, the more anxious and activated you become.
Neither person is wrong. You’re just stuck in a pattern that keeps both of you feeling unsafe.
What to Do When Your Partner Pulls Away
Here’s the good news: You don’t have to stay stuck in this dance. While you can’t change your partner’s attachment style overnight, you can create small shifts that lead to more trust, more safety, and more connection.
- Pause and Regulate Before Reacting
When your partner withdraws, your nervous system may go into fight-or-flight. Take a breath. Step back—not in disconnection, but in self-regulation.
Ask yourself:
- What’s happening inside me right now?
- Am I feeling rejected, abandoned, scared?
- What does my nervous system need?
Grounding techniques like deep breathing, a short walk, or holding something cold can help you respond from a calmer place.
- Don’t Chase—Get Curious
Good timing is crucial! Ask your partner if it is a good time to talk. If not now when? Instead of jumping to “What’s wrong with you?” try:
“I noticed you seemed distant earlier. Is everything okay? I just want to understand—no pressure.”
Use “I” statements to describe how you felt without making assumptions or accusations.
This creates emotional safety—and may open a door your partner didn’t know how to unlock.
- Give Them Space—But Not Silence
Avoidant partners often fear being overwhelmed or engulfed. Giving them space can help—but healthy space doesn’t mean disappearing.
Try:
“Take the time you need, and I’ll be here when you’re ready to talk.”
This honors their need for autonomy while keeping the connection alive.
- Name the Pattern Together
If you’re both open, gently explore the dynamic as something you’re both in, not something one person is doing wrong. You are a system and when one part of the system changes it impacts the other part.
“I’ve noticed that when I reach out, sometimes you pull away. I’m wondering if there’s something I could do differently, or if we could talk about what comes up for you when I try to get close.”
This is a vulnerability bridge, not a demand.
- Explore Attachment Styles and Triggers
Understanding your own and your partner’s attachment style can transform how you view each other.
- Avoidant partners may need help naming emotions and trusting closeness.
- Anxious partners may need help self-soothing and tolerating space.
The goal isn’t to change each other—it’s to understand each other and meet in a place of mutual compassion.
How Therapy Can Help Shift This Pattern
You don’t have to figure this out on your own.
Couple therapy—especially approaches like Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT)—can help partners:
- Understand and shift attachment dynamics
- Practice new, secure ways of connecting
- Heal past relationship injuries
- Learn how to express needs without triggering each other’s fears
And individual therapy can also help you explore your own patterns, boundaries, and needs with clarity and support. If you are dealing with childhood wounds that are impacting your relationship EMDR can help heal the wounds that may be contributing to an insecure attachment style.
If You’re the One Who Pulls Away…
If you’ve been the one who withdraws when things get emotional, you’re not broken or unloving. You may just be protecting yourself in the only way you know how.
You might ask yourself:
- What does closeness bring up for me?
- When have I felt unsafe being emotionally vulnerable?
- Is there a part of me that believes I’ll lose myself if I let someone in?
Healing avoidance doesn’t mean forcing closeness—it means learning to stay present long enough to trust that it’s safe to stay.
You Can Love Each Other Without Losing Yourselves
The dance between closeness and distance can be frustrating, but it doesn’t have to be the end of the story.
With honesty, self-awareness, and gentle effort, couples can move from survival mode to secure connection—from fear to understanding.
And that kind of love? It’s not only possible—it’s worth it.
If you and your partner are stuck in a pattern of disconnection, reach out to a therapist trained in attachment or couples therapy. Support is here for both of you.
Reviewed and edited by Susan Packer RP, M-Div counselling (Registered Psychotherapist) at Finding Solutions Together.
Recent Comments